The short version
- Pick your neighborhoods before you tour. Drive them in the morning, afternoon and evening.
- Your first home doesn't have to be your forever home.
- Sellers care about price, terms and timing. A strong approval can beat a higher but shakier offer.
- Contingencies protect your deposit. Release them only after you've checked everything.
- Once you're in contract, don't change the picture. No new debt, no moving money and no job changes without calling your lender first.
How do you pick the right neighborhood?
Narrow down your areas before you start touring. If you're torn between El Dorado Hills and Auburn, drive both. Go have dinner there. Visit in the morning, the afternoon and the evening. Then pick the neighborhoods you like best, so you're not wasting weekends (and gas) driving all over.
Next, sort your wants from your needs. Do you need four bedrooms, or would three and a den work? Do you want a pool, or would you rather pay less and maybe add one later? And don't trust the photos alone. Wide-angle shots can make a small yard or a tight kitchen look huge.
If schools matter, call the school district and confirm the address. School lines don't always follow city lines. My wife Jennifer and I learned this the hard way. We built our dream home in the Bay Area in 2005. Then our kids came along, and we realized the schools weren't right for our family. About 10 months later, we sold and moved to Rocklin. Jennifer's list was simple: single story, at least 2,500 square feet and great schools.
Does your first home have to be your forever home?
No. I tell first-time buyers that you're not necessarily buying your dream home. You're buying a home to get in the game and start building equity. Many buyers move up within several years as life changes, and some keep their first home as a rental. Either way, the equity from your first home helps you buy the next one.
So don't pay for space you don't need. If it's just one or two of you, a 3,000 square foot house may just mean a bigger payment for empty rooms.
Is the highest offer always the best offer?
Not always. Put yourself in the seller's shoes. Many sellers were first-time buyers a few years ago, and now they're moving up. They often need this sale to close so they can buy their next home.
So a seller looks at more than price. They look at terms and timing. An offer that is a little higher but depends on the buyer selling another home, needs a long escrow or has a weak approval may not be the strongest offer. As a first-time buyer, you have one big advantage: you don't have a home to sell.
Can a financed offer beat a cash offer?
Yes, and it happens more than people think. Cash buyers often feel powerful, so they offer low. Alicia recently had a cash buyer who wrote five offers and lost all five to financed buyers with solid approvals and higher prices. On one home listed at $774,000, her cash buyer offered $720,000, and the seller didn't even respond.
A financed buyer who comes in a bit higher, with a fully reviewed approval and an agent who builds trust with the listing agent, can win.
What is an earnest money deposit?
When you write an offer, your agent will ask for an earnest money deposit, often 1% to 3% of the price. Be ready for it, along with proof that you have the funds.
The deposit isn't an extra cost. It goes toward your down payment and closing costs. For example, if your down payment is $50,000 and you put down a $20,000 deposit, you bring the other $30,000 at closing. A bigger deposit can also show the seller you're serious.
What do contingencies actually protect?
Contingencies protect your deposit. They give you a way to back out if something important goes wrong. There are usually three:
- Loan contingency. If your loan falls through, you can cancel and keep your deposit. This is why a fully reviewed approval matters so much.
- Appraisal contingency. If the home appraises for less than your price, you can renegotiate or cancel and keep your deposit.
- Inspection contingency. This is your time to check the home. The standard California contract gives you 17 days, and we sometimes shorten it to make your offer stronger.
Alicia recommends a general home inspection, a pest inspection for termites and dry rot, a look at the roof and a sewer line inspection. Tree roots can grow into old sewer pipes, and you don't want to find that out after you move in. In the country, add septic and well inspections. Also make sure you can get homeowners insurance at a price you can afford. That's especially important in the foothills, where fire insurance can be expensive.
Inspectors are supposed to nitpick everything, from a loose outlet to a rusty gutter. That helps us decide what really matters.
Should you ask for repairs or a credit?
Often a credit is better. If the seller makes repairs during escrow, they may choose the fastest, cheapest fix. With a credit, you choose the contractor.
We usually ask for the credit toward your closing costs. That lowers the cash you need at closing, and you can use the money you kept to make repairs after you move in. A credit can't be more than your actual closing costs, and loan programs limit how much a seller can give. Serious safety issues may still need to be fixed before closing, so we plan the right approach together.
How do you win when you're not the highest offer?
My clients get what I call a Fastpass approval. Before you shop, we do the full review: a credit check with all three bureaus, two months of bank statements and verified income. When we're done, you're almost like a buyer with a check ready to go.
That lets you compete on more than price. You might close in 21 days, or even 15, instead of 30. You might shorten your contingency periods. In the Bay Area, many of my buyers write offers with no contingencies at all, which only makes sense when your approval has been fully checked. With a big enough down payment, some buyers can even waive the appraisal contingency.
Your offer doesn't have to be the highest. It has to give the seller the number they need, with confidence that you'll close.
What can blow up your loan before closing?
Think of your approval like a puzzle we built together. If you don't change the pieces, the picture stays the same. Here's what changes the pieces:
- Moving money between banks. If we approved you with statements from one bank and you move everything to another, we now have to document every move.
- Changing or quitting your job. Years ago, a client asked me at the signing table what could still break her deal. I joked, "Quit your job." On Monday, when we went to verify her job, she had quit. Even a promotion can matter, especially if your pay or overtime changes.
- Paying off a car or other debt. It sounds smart, but your approval may count on the savings you have left.
- New debt. Don't finance furniture or a new fridge at 0% before closing. Watch buy now, pay later plans too.
- Travel. Being out of the country during escrow can make signing much harder. Tell us your plans early.
Life happens. Just call me first, so we can plan around it.
What comes next?
You made it through the offer, the inspections and the loan approval. In Part 3, we cover everything between contract and keys. Missed the start? Read Part 1: realtor or lender first.
Want an approval that sellers trust?
Book a free 20-minute conversation. We'll talk about your goals and how to make your offer strong, with no pressure.
Questions from this episode
Is the highest offer always the best offer?
No. Sellers look at price, terms and timing. A slightly lower offer with a strong approval and a quick, simple close can beat a higher offer that is harder to close.
Can a financed offer beat a cash offer?
Yes. Cash buyers often offer low. A financed buyer with a fully reviewed approval and a better price can win, and it happens more than people think.
How much is an earnest money deposit?
Often 1% to 3% of the price. It isn't an extra cost. It goes toward your down payment and closing costs.
What does a loan contingency protect?
Your deposit. If your loan falls through during the contingency period, you can cancel the purchase and get your deposit back.
What should I avoid before closing?
Don't move money between banks, take on new debt, pay off large debts or change jobs without talking to your lender first. Keep your finances the same until you have the keys.