Home / Blog / Can insurance stop the deal?

Covered: The California HOI Series, Part 1

Can homeowners insurance stop you from buying a house in California?

Yes, it can. Your lender needs proof of homeowners insurance before your loan can close, and the insurance cost is part of the payment you qualify for. A high quote can shrink your buying power, and a home no one will insure can't be financed. In Part 1 of our Covered series, Alicia Wright of eXp Realty, insurance broker Renee Inman of Acrisure and I explain how to check insurance early so it never surprises you.

Watch the full episode on YouTube. The written guide below covers the key points.

The short version

  • No insurance, no loan. Get a real quote early, before you're deep into escrow.
  • Your dwelling coverage is the cost to rebuild your home, not the price you paid. Land isn't insured.
  • A higher deductible can lower your premium. Insurance isn't a home warranty.
  • Past claims follow both the person and the property. Ask about claims history before you write an offer.
  • The FAIR Plan isn't scary, but on its own it mostly covers fire. Pair it with a wrap policy for full coverage.

Why can insurance stop a home purchase?

You found the house. You qualified for the loan. You still might not be able to buy it. Why? Because a lender needs proof of homeowners insurance before your loan can close. No insurance, no loan.

Insurance also matters before that. When I qualify you, I use your whole payment: principal, interest, property taxes and insurance. If you're buying near the top of your budget and the insurance quote comes in much higher than we planned, it can lower how much house you can buy.

That's why Alicia and I sat down with Renee Inman, an insurance broker with Acrisure. This is Part 1 of our Covered series on California homeowners insurance.

What does a standard homeowners policy cover?

Renee explained that a standard policy covers things like fire, storms, wind, theft and liability. Inside the policy are different parts:

  • Dwelling: the house itself.
  • Personal property: your belongings. Renee's tip: if you turned your house upside down and shook it, everything that falls out is personal property.
  • Liability: if someone gets hurt at your home and sues you.
  • Loss of use: if your home becomes unlivable, this helps pay for a place to stay while it's repaired.

What about a dog bite? Renee said it depends. Some policies exclude dog bite liability. If yours doesn't, it may be covered. Read your policy or ask your broker.

Does homeowners insurance cover flood or earthquake?

No. The California Department of Insurance says a standard policy doesn't cover flood or earthquake. Each is its own separate policy. In California, insurers must offer you earthquake coverage, but you choose whether to buy it.

Flood insurance becomes a must if your home is in a high-risk flood zone and you have a loan from a federally regulated lender. By law, the lender has to require it. I had a client in the Bay Area whose home was newly mapped into a flood zone. He wanted to fight it. He had to buy flood insurance anyway, and that same year his house flooded. He was very glad he had it.

Why do two houses on the same street get different prices?

Renee said that even on the same street, prices can differ because of:

  • The roof type and how updated the home is.
  • The home's claims history.
  • The owner's own claims history, even from a different home.
  • The deductible you choose.

How much dwelling coverage do you need?

The most common mix-up Renee sees: people expect the dwelling coverage to match the purchase price. It usually doesn't, and that's okay. Dwelling coverage is the cost to rebuild your home with today's construction costs. It doesn't cover the land.

I see this all the time in the Bay Area. A 1,000 square foot home might sell for $1.5 million or more, but the premium can be lower than people expect, because it's based on what it costs to rebuild a 1,000 square foot house, not the price.

Being underinsured is a problem. Being overinsured can be one too, because you may be paying more for no reason.

Should you choose a higher deductible?

Often, yes. A $1,000 deductible feels good. But Renee pointed out that most people rarely file a claim that small. In her experience, going from a $1,000 to a $2,500 deductible can save you hundreds of dollars a year. The Department of Insurance agrees that a larger deductible can lower your premium.

Think of it this way: insurance isn't a home warranty. A higher deductible also keeps you from filing small claims you could handle yourself, which protects your claims history for later.

What is a CLUE report, and how long do claims follow a home?

A CLUE report is the insurance claims history. Renee explained that claims are tied to the person who filed them and to the home itself. A CLUE report can show up to 7 years of claims, and Renee says the insurers she works with mostly look back about 5 years.

So filing a claim today could affect selling your home later. And if you're buying, a seller's recent claim can raise your quote. I had a buyer recently where the listing agent told us what the sellers paid. Once we were in contract, the real quote came in much higher because of a recent claim. We made it work, but it could have changed what that buyer qualified for.

Two more things Renee said: a clean report doesn't mean nothing ever happened, only that nothing went through insurance. And a past claim doesn't mean you can't get insured. Homeowners can request their own free CLUE report from LexisNexis once a year, so a seller can pull it ahead of time.

Can a seller's insurance policy transfer to the buyer?

Alicia had a buyer ask her for the seller's declarations page and whether the policy could transfer. Renee said that, to her knowledge, homeowners policies don't transfer to a new owner. A listing agent can get a soft quote on a listing to share with buyers. Just know the buyer's own claims history isn't in that number, so the final quote can change.

How early can a buyer get a real quote?

Early. Renee says if she has your name, date of birth and current address, she can run the quote for real, including your claims history. Once you're in contract and sign the application, the price is the price. She doesn't need your Social Security number, and some carriers give a small discount when you share your current address.

After you buy, the insurance company may inspect the home. Sometimes it's a drone you never see. Sometimes someone knocks on your door. Some carriers let you send photos yourself, and Renee says that can come with a discount.

Are insurance companies coming back to California?

Renee says yes, slowly. Companies that stopped writing new policies are starting to come back, and more companies means more options. The Department of Insurance reported in September 2026 that State Farm and Allstate had both filed to start writing new home policies again. At that time, neither was taking new customers yet, and the filings were still under review.

What should you do if you get a non-renewal notice?

Don't panic. First, look at the date. California law says your insurer must mail a non-renewal notice at least 75 days before your policy ends, so you usually have time. Then call your broker. Renee says her team starts shopping 30 to 60 days before the non-renewal date.

What is the California FAIR Plan?

The FAIR Plan was built to be the insurance of last resort. When companies pulled back, a lot of homeowners were pushed into it. Renee says it isn't scary when it's done right.

On its own, the FAIR Plan mostly covers fire, lightning and smoke, with a few add-ons like vandalism. It doesn't include liability. That's why you pair it with a wrap policy, also called a difference in conditions policy. The wrap adds liability, belongings and more. Together, they make full coverage. Renee won't sell the FAIR Plan without the wrap, because that's not in the client's best interest.

Alicia has seen homes that never needed special fire coverage suddenly need it, even down the hill in places like Folsom and Fairfield. The good news: Renee says it's loosening up. In places like West Roseville where the FAIR Plan used to be the only choice, her team has found other options.

Can you lower your wildfire insurance costs?

A little. California's Safer from Wildfires rules give discounts for steps like clearing defensible space around your home and living in a Firewise USA community. Renee's honest take: it helps, but the discount isn't large. A fire hydrant within about 1,000 feet of your home can make a bigger difference. You can't choose where the hydrant is, but if you're picking between two homes, it's worth asking.

What should you check before you buy, and every year after?

Before you write an offer, Renee would check the insurance cost and the claims history, then compare the yearly cost with your second-choice home. Let the numbers do the talking.

Once you're in your home, check two things every year: your deductible, and whether your dwelling coverage still matches what it would cost to rebuild today. When I do an annual mortgage review with my clients, we look at their insurance too. If they're paying too much, I reach out to Renee to see if there's room to improve.

The biggest lesson from this episode: build your team early. Your agent, your lender and your insurance broker should all talk to each other. Get the education up front, and insurance won't surprise you at the finish line.

Want to know how insurance changes your buying power?

Book a free 20-minute conversation. We'll run your full payment, including taxes and insurance, so there are no surprises in escrow.

Questions from this episode

Can I get a mortgage without homeowners insurance?

No. Your lender needs proof of homeowners insurance before your loan can close. The cost of insurance is also part of the monthly payment you qualify for.

Does homeowners insurance cover flood or earthquake in California?

No. A standard policy doesn't cover either one. Each is a separate policy. Flood insurance is required if your home is in a high-risk flood zone and your loan is from a federally regulated lender.

Why is my dwelling coverage lower than my purchase price?

Dwelling coverage is the cost to rebuild your home, not its market value. It doesn't include the land, so it is often lower than what you paid, especially in the Bay Area.

What is a CLUE report?

It's a report of insurance claims tied to a person and to a property. It can show up to 7 years of claims. A homeowner can request a free copy from LexisNexis once a year.

What is the California FAIR Plan?

It's the insurance of last resort for homes that can't get coverage elsewhere. On its own it mostly covers fire and doesn't include liability, so it's paired with a wrap, or difference in conditions, policy for full coverage.

How much notice do I get before my policy is non-renewed?

In California, your insurer must mail a non-renewal notice at least 75 days before your policy ends. Call your broker right away so they can start shopping.

Keep reading